United States: Defined Benefit Plan Participants Have Standing To Pursue Fiduciary Breach Claims

A federal district court in Minnesota found that participants in a defined benefit pension plan had standing to assert claims that defendants breached their fiduciary duties by, among other things, shifting to an equities-only investment strategy that resulted in the plan becoming significantly underfunded and thereby increasing the risk of default.  In so ruling, the court determined that even though U.S. Bancorp was capable of meeting its minimum funding obligations, plaintiffs plausibly alleged that […]

By | December 4th, 2014 ||

United States: Avoiding Liability For Retaliation Claims: Issue Spotting In Real Time

Introduction
Retaliation lawsuits are the most common claims brought against employers before governmental agencies and are increasing in frequency in the civil court system. According to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), in 2013, a retaliation claim was made in 41.1% of all charges submitted to the EEOC. This is more than discrimination based on race and more than discrimination based on disability. Even more concerning is the consistent uptick in retaliation allegations. Retaliation claims […]

By | December 4th, 2014 ||

Canada: "Zero Tolerance", Automatic Suspension Approach To Safety Violations Criticized, Written Warning Substituted

Employers are increasingly taking a “zero tolerance” approach in which a minimum level of discipline – whether a suspension or dismissal – is imposed for certain serious safety violations. In a recent case, an arbitrator criticized the approach as unfair to the employee.

Plant security, conducting a random vehicle search as the employee left the premises, found a partially-consumed bottle of flavoured vodka beneath some camping equipment in the trunk of the vehicle.  The employee […]

By | December 2nd, 2014 ||